Where zirconia outperforms alumina
Impact and sliding wear: transformation toughening gives zirconia a fracture toughness several times that of alumina. A zirconia valve part or nozzle chips less when a hard particle hits it or a seat slides against it.
Smooth surfaces: Blasch zirconia takes a very smooth surface with a low coefficient of friction, useful where solids slide or metal has to flow without picking up deposits.
Joints with steel: the modulus of elasticity and thermal expansion of Blasch zirconia are close to steel. In a metal holder or flange, both parts grow by a similar amount as they heat up, which keeps stress at the joint low.
Aggressive melts: an alumina zirconia composite resists nickel, cobalt and stainless melts better than plain alumina. Blasch uses it for crucibles, tundishes, launders and nozzles in aerospace, medical and industrial alloy production.
Where alumina remains the better choice
Cost: zirconia is the more expensive oxide. Blasch developed its high alumina ProCaster crucibles as a replacement for zirconia crucibles in many alloys, and keeps zirconia for the melts that need it.
Heat transfer: zirconia conducts heat poorly. That makes it a good insulator, but a poor choice for a heater tube or a thermocouple sheath that has to pass heat quickly; there, silicon carbide or silicon nitride fits.
Long exposure at high temperature: stabilized zirconia can slowly lose its stabilized structure in some atmospheres and temperature ranges. For a part that sits hot for months, the grade and stabilizer have to be chosen with the operating profile.